Joanna Newsom

clockworkwombat 書き込み：

hoom used to be my least fave b/c of the production, but i got over it ... wish she waited a little longer to record it though because her voice seems significantly more recovered now, i think it's the technical things in the sound that mess it up for me, not the songs themselves

clockworkwombat に一言コメントを残す

mic180 書き込み：

@MilkyMoon14 I'm working on Mender! Ys is where I began with Joanna, in 2007 I think. Monkey & Bear was the first track I ever heard. I can't claim to have been hooked but it was unique and intriguing enough to make me want to listen to more of her. I liked Joanna, but HOoM has made me love her something fierce. I think it's the best album I've ever heard. I ignored it for a few years, but made up for lost time. In about half a year it's my top played album :D I too should probably sleep, seeing as how it's nearly 4am...

mic180 に一言コメントを残す

MilkyMoon14 書き込み：

@mic180 I found your comment right-on. HOOM is a good place to start with Newsom, and I promise you that you'll come to adore Mender. And yes, rightly said, every song on HOOM is just out there. Everything Newsom sings is utterly beyond comparison. :D. So now I'll stop spamming the Joanna shoutbox and find something better to do, preferably sleep.

MilkyMoon14 に一言コメントを残す

RobHF 書き込み：

urg '81 is just perfect <3

RobHF に一言コメントを残す

mic180 書き込み：

HOoM is her BEST album. But that's just my own opinion. That being said, I don't criticize her previous works or anyone who feels differently. It's music, we all experience it differently, as MilkyMoon14 below said. I enjoyed Ys very much and am still trying to get into TM-EM. But HOoM is on another level completely. I can't even begin to describe how amazing this album is and how much I love it. If I were to choose 3 songs from that album to play on repeat forever it'd be Ribbon Bows, Esm... nvm, I take it back. I can't decide.

mic180 に一言コメントを残す

MilkyMoon14 書き込み：

How about we say that all of Joannas work is good, because that's very true. Every single song that she sings is powerful and emotional, and it doesn't matter if she sounds different in Mender than in HOOM. Different people will, of course, enjoy different music. All that matters is if you like it or don't like it, and that's your choice. Meanwhile, over In California...

MilkyMoon14 に一言コメントを残す

CaseyDeAnn 書き込み：

Have One on Me is her only album I have enjoyed thus far. In fact, I loved it upon my first listen. Her vocal change, for whatever reason, is for the best.

CaseyDeAnn に一言コメントを残す

classmates 書き込み：

I don't understand why anyone is taking out their precious time to degrade one of the most influential artists of our generation, really. If you want to bitch, visit Ke$ha's last.fm page or something, jesus.

classmates に一言コメントを残す

SpiritOfYetaxa 書き込み：

I admit I hated HOoM at first because of the voice and the fact that all the songs sounded the same, but then I took some interest and listened more. It's a great album

SpiritOfYetaxa に一言コメントを残す

puismourir 書き込み：

and if you think HOOM is bad because her voice is different, I suggest you actually listen to the music, lyrics, etc...?

puismourir に一言コメントを残す

puismourir 書き込み：

oh my god. of all the stupid things that go in this shoutbox, this probably tops them all. artists develop and explore, get over it.

puismourir に一言コメントを残す

HeySharpshooter 書き込み：

A common issue it seems... Not going to call her a liar, as those things do happen, though many a singer has made similar claims in the past to cover up for a change. Have One On Me is not a bad record. It just doesn't compare to her previous work.

HeySharpshooter に一言コメントを残す

GenryAi 書き込み：

She didn't change her vocal approach because of whiners, she developed vocal cord nodules in the spring of 2009 and recovering from it changed her voice. She stated in an interview she could not sing with the same vocals as she did before even if she wanted to.

GenryAi に一言コメントを残す

HeySharpshooter 書き込み：

The issue with Have One On Me is that she changed her vocal approach... she gave it to those who whined and bitched about the vocals on Milk Eyed Mender and Y's.

HeySharpshooter に一言コメントを残す

ksjn 書き込み：

why must a voice be ordinary for you to feel natural listening to it? ..this topic is getting old

ksjn に一言コメントを残す

hljott 書き込み：

so gorgeous in portlandia!

hljott に一言コメントを残す

BarneyJWY 書き込み：

How about people just like Joanna because she's unique and her music is different in a good way. We're not trying to be cool, we actually like her music. No one pretends to like music.

BarneyJWY に一言コメントを残す

sticker14 書き込み：

The Milk-Eyed Mender, always and forever.

sticker14 に一言コメントを残す