シャウト
-
-
-
-
-
closerandcloser
it sounds nice but acoustic guitar on the beginning is similar to... dogs by pink floyd(!)
操作
-
-
-
Ant17
Get off your high horses, internet (lolmusic) users. It's like when you read a book - you can analyse the crap out of it and discuss the literary symbology with your noses up, or you can enjoy the damn story. Nice sentimental song, and a darn good video, too. I wasn't a fan of FOABP, and half of Deadwing I loved, the other half I didn't - but this is a great start to an album I hope I will enjoy. Video here: http://www.muzu.tv/porcupinetree
操作
-
colourofsleep
Nothing special really, but I think it's a good indication that the 55 minute song is going to be pretty epic.
操作
-
-
このシャウトは表示できません。
-
-
-
-
-
-
jhuk
Absolutely stunning - this has completely destroyed me! Understand the 'Floyd references the difference is that Wilson is a talented songwriter, and presumably this is band arranged (only person by the time of Animals who could really play their instrument with feeling was Gilmour). Porcupine Tree have an art of using chords and feel to produce a real atmosphere. Have to disagree with the comment below re the lyrics - these are honest and beautiful and meld with the music perfectly just as as well as the sinister/darker stuff. For atrocious lyrics see the middle section of Anesthetize etc... Interesting reading the reactions tho :-)
操作
-
-
kourinthellama
The lyrics are atrocious, but overall it's good. I just wish Steven would stop playing around with the way he sings, it sounds really peculiar at times.
操作
-
-
-
-
-
sandrob57
My first impression of the radio edit: It's ok, I wish it weren't an edit though so I could truly judge the song. The song seems less 'natural', almost like Steven is trying to force it. Stuff like Lightbulb sun and Stupid Dream came too naturally; I don't think the man can redo it. I'm not saying it isn't good, it's just...not the same. It doesn't have that same impact. I'm currently on my second play through, and I'm already liking it a little more (I can actually pick out Colin on the bass this time).
操作