Original Broadway Cast

NeoAnjou 書き込み：

I think a lot of the debate would end if the description were made less patronising. The 'do yourself a favor' line really rubs me up the wrong way, and is needlessly hostile. A switch to a more gentle and positive description might actually get people to change their artists, something like: 'Original Broadway Cast' is a generic artist label used for various Broadway shows. Last FM recommends that rather than using the generic cast label changing your tags, to include the actual artist name in the artist field, so that artists can receive the plays they deserver and statistics can be kept clean.'

NeoAnjou に一言コメントを残す

samsnicefm 書き込み：

Finale is the best song ever.

samsnicefm に一言コメントを残す

fakehead 書き込み：

How long has this debate been going? Since the birth of last.fm? Nothing has changed since, and it's obvious that nothing will. It's time to put a lid on it.

fakehead に一言コメントを残す

love_conquers 書き込み：

I plan on keeping the OBC tag, since I use it to differentiate between different casts. Some show originally start in London, in which case I use Original London Cast. Some shows start Off-Broadway, so I use Original Off-Broadway cast and so on and so forth. I'd rather not have Adam Pascal/Heather Headley, Sherie Rene Scott/Adam Pascal/Heather Headley, and Heather Headley/Sherie Rene Scott as three separate artists in my library under one album, when I can simplify them down into Original Broadway Cast as the artist and have the album as Aida.

love_conquers に一言コメントを残す

hugocaladohc 書き込み：

The Little Mermaid ♥

hugocaladohc に一言コメントを残す

Moz_Smiths 書き込み：

Hasa Diga Eebowai :)

Moz_Smiths に一言コメントを残す

Olina23 書き込み：

i actually add the cast as the artist name and leave it like that whether or not last.fm changes it!

Olina23 に一言コメントを残す

lorata 書き込み：

As PurpleCow17 said, tagging Broadway shows by the composer is idiotic. How are you supposed to tell whether it's the original cast, 10th Anniversary Cast, etc., if it's all listed under "Stephen Sondheim" or whatnot?

lorata に一言コメントを残す

promisedeyes 書き込み：

The Internet Is for Porn (?) ;-3

promisedeyes に一言コメントを残す

liftarn 書き込み：

You would not be alone. Last.fm looks at Musicbrainz for guidelines how to tag music and just look at http://musicbrainz.org/doc/Style/Specific_types_of_releases/Theatre

liftarn に一言コメントを残す

PurpleCow17 書き込み：

I could if I wasn't using Last.fm. Since nobody else tags their tracks like that, I would most likely be the sole listener for each and every showtune I own, thus eliminating a large part of the social portion of the site, which is a large portion of what I like. Also - and admittedly this is a less serious issue, and I'd certainly learn to deal with it if I ever did switch everything over - that's an ugly tag, especially for horrifically long cast recording names, such as "Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat (1968 London Concept Album)." It also feels like a waste of my available tags - like now I should use the album tag for something else, since it would essentially be a repeat of the artist. There are pros and cons for all the different tagging options but none of them are ideal.

PurpleCow17 に一言コメントを残す

liftarn 書き込み：

If you tag the albums as "Show Name (production)" you would be able to tell them apart.

liftarn に一言コメントを残す

PurpleCow17 書き込み：

It's nice to pretend there's a simple solution here, but there simply isn't. I'm not a fan of the "Original Broadway Cast" tag (as it does tend to lump a bunch of unconnected shows together) but tagging the composer as the artist is crazy unhelpful for Broadway cast recordings. The plethora of *different* cast recordings of the same show (not to mention composer demos) means that I should have four or five different songs titled "This is the Moment," all listed with Frank Wildhorn as the artist, but all recorded by different singers from different casts. The best solution I've come up with is tagging each individual song by the actual singers performing, which makes MusicBrainz mad but, honestly, it functions as a cover. Why would I tag a cover as being by the original artist rather than the artist singing it?

PurpleCow17 に一言コメントを残す

airfigaro 書き込み：

I wish I could change tags imported from mog.com when I listen to a show. This is the silliest tag.

airfigaro に一言コメントを残す

pockyy 書き込み：

ooo..new picture

pockyy に一言コメントを残す

liftarn 書き込み：

@Sheikm: Listing by composer is what makes most sense and it's also policy, see http://musicbrainz.org/doc/Musical_Soundtrack_Style It certainly makes more sense that using artificial artists like the album name, location where it was performed or simply as Soundtrack like many do.

liftarn に一言コメントを残す

Sheikm 書き込み：

It's mostly that the site seems obsessed by listing everything by composer, which... well, it's kinda lacking in the sense department, if anything.

Sheikm に一言コメントを残す

liftarn 書き込み：

@Sheikm: Please explain. I am aware that every album in existence is not listed at MusicBrainz. If so you can help out by adding it. As for "ridiculous suggestions" I think you need to explain that as well.

liftarn に一言コメントを残す